While carpets were historically a favorite of homeowners, several important issues have surfaced around their potential human toxicity. Most carpets are made from synthetic materials, including nylon, polyester, acrylic, latex, polyvinyl chloride (PVC), 4-phenyl cyclohexane, and polyurethane. Besides being petroleum-based, these synthetic materials, the adhesives used to bind the carpet to the floor, and popular chemical stain repellants off-gas VOCs into the home, thus compromising indoor air quality.
Moreover, carpets naturally attract and hold allergens that further impair indoor air quality. Finally, from a waste perspective, the non-biodegradable nature of carpet means that carpet discards take vast amounts of space in landfills.
Hardwood flooring, on the other hand, is sourced from a renewable resource: trees. Laminate flooring and MDF flooring can contain formaldehyde and other off-gassing chemicals. So, where possible, most homeowners prefer solid wood products.
You can find beautiful wood flooring made from sustainably sourced lumber. However, reports often surface related to the unsustainable management of lumber. For example, a report in 2017 recounted how US timber distributors, including the leading wood supplier for Home Depot, were fueling massive deforestation in the rain forests of Papua New Guinea. This is despite their original claims of sustainable forestry practices along their supply chain.
While tile flooring is durable and sourced from one of the most abundant resources on earth (dirt), homeowners rarely consider other environmental considerations. One report on tile flooring in Asia concluded that ceramic tile flooring had a significant ecological impact. The impact stems from massive greenhouse gas emissions related to the double-firing process during manufacture and heavy material transportation across long distances. Tile, therefore, can have a large embodied energy footprint.